# Reship or refund? *See which path costs less.*

A not-received or damaged ticket lands and the agent has to choose now. This calculator runs the break-even formula from our reship vs refund guide: net cost of a reship against net cost of a refund, using your numbers for this order.

Some links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Drafted with AI, checked by a human. [How we earn](https://storevetted.com/disclosure/).

- Your own numbers
- Every formula shown
- Runs in your browser

Calculating…

## How the math works

This is the formula from our [reship vs refund break-even guide](https://storevetted.com/guides/reship-vs-refund-break-even-shopify/):

- **Cost of a reship** = landed product cost + reship postage − claim expected value − (chance the original parcel is found × value recovered).
- **Cost of a refund** = order value refunded − claim expected value + future margin you lose if the customer does not come back.

The original outbound postage and the first unit’s product cost are sunk in both paths, so they are left out. File the claim when the terms allow it — recovery is subtracted on both sides unless your policy says a replacement changes what you can claim. If the customer has already opened a card or PayPal dispute, do not reship and refund the same order. Ops comparison, not legal advice.

[Put the reship/refund decision in Gorgias macros](https://storevetted.com/go/gorgias)

Keep going

## Related free tools

[All 81 tools](https://storevetted.com/tools/)

[Return cost calculator](https://storevetted.com/return-cost-calculator/): What returns cost per month: shipping, labour, write-offs.

[WISMO ticket cost estimator](https://storevetted.com/wismo-ticket-cost-estimator/): NEW What “where is my order?” tickets cost in staff time each month.

[Claims cost calculator](https://storevetted.com/claims-cost-calculator/): What lost, damaged and returned orders really cost you.

## FAQ

When should I reship instead of refund?

When the reship path’s net cost is lower, the item is in stock, and the customer will accept a replacement. If postage eats the margin, or the customer wants their money back, the refund path is cheaper.

Is there a standard break-even AOV?

No. It depends on your margin, the lane’s postage and your own claim history. The defaults are example math, not benchmarks.

Should I count the first shipment’s postage?

No. That cost is already spent whether you reship or refund, so the formula leaves it out.

What if I am out of stock?

Uncheck “the item is in stock.” The calculator then treats a refund as the only path.

From the guides

## Related guides

[All guides](https://storevetted.com/guides/)

- [Reship vs refund break-even](https://storevetted.com/guides/reship-vs-refund-break-even-shopify/)
- [Delivered, not received](https://storevetted.com/guides/delivered-but-not-received/)
- [Wrong item sent / mis-pick](https://storevetted.com/guides/customer-received-wrong-item-shopify/)

---

Canonical: https://storevetted.com/reship-vs-refund-calculator/  
Publisher: StoreVetted (https://storevetted.com/). Some links may earn a commission at no cost to you: https://storevetted.com/disclosure/  
Site index for agents: https://storevetted.com/llms.txt
