Claims cost calculator: what lost, damaged and returned orders cost you
Lost parcels, damaged items, wrong orders, returns and chargebacks all land in your inbox. Enter your own numbers to see the monthly cost of staff time, refunds or reships and dispute fees — then the helpdesk that fits your volume.
Some links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Drafted with AI, checked by a human. How we earn.
1,000 orders a month at $60, claims on 3% of orders, 15 minutes of handling at $20 an hour, half of claims ending in a refund or reship with $8 extra shipping, 20% of that recovered, and 2 chargebacks a month with a $15 fee, 60% lost.
Line
Formula
Per month
Staff time
30 claims × 15 min × $20/h
$150
Refunds and reships
15 × ($60 + $8) = $1,020, minus 20% recovered
$816
Chargeback fees
2 × $15
$30
Chargebacks lost
2 × 60% × $60
$72
Total
$1.07 per order shipped
$1,068
The calculator’s default example numbers, not benchmarks.
How much can you recover from carriers?
The recovery percentage is yours to enter, and it depends mostly on filing inside each carrier’s window with the right paperwork. From the official pages opened 16 Nov 2026 (MYT):
USPS pays only on insured mail: it “may not legally pay compensation for uninsured lost or damaged articles”, and never more than the item’s actual value (USPS).
UPS: start within 60 days of the scheduled delivery; keep the invoice, the contents and the packaging (UPS).
FedEx: damage within 60 calendar days of the shipment date (US), lost within nine months, with proof-of-value documents (FedEx).
Evri (UK, without Full Cover): the lesser of £20 and the goods’ value, plus the charges; business senders must notify within 28 days (Evri Terms 3.7, 7.3).
NRF and Happy Returns estimate US shoppers would return about $849.9B of merchandise in 2025, a 15.8% overall return rate and 19.3% for online sales; retailers estimated 9% of returns were fraudulent. NRF 2025 Retail Returns Landscape
SafeWise estimates 104.3 million packages were stolen in the US over 12 months (about 250,000 a day). SafeWise package theft report
Stripe charges a $15 dispute fee, plus a $15 counter fee if you choose to contest (refunded if you win). Stripe docs. Other processors differ — check yours.
These are industry-wide figures, not predictions for your store. The calculator only uses the numbers you type in.
Free download
Now track what each claim costs you.
The free Claims Ops Kit Lite gives you one claims log in Excel or Google Sheets. Pick the carrier and the sheet works out the last day to file, so fewer claims slip past the window and become a write-off.
Add up three parts: staff time (minutes per claim × hourly cost ÷ 60), money paid out (refunds or reships, plus extra shipping, minus anything you recover from the carrier, an insurer or resale), and fees such as chargeback fees. This calculator does exactly that with the numbers you enter.
Are the default numbers industry averages?
No. The defaults are example assumptions so the tool shows a result straight away. Replace them with your own figures from your helpdesk, payment processor and order data.
Which helpdesk is best for handling claims?
It depends on volume and channels. Low-volume stores can start on free plans (Help Scout Free, Tidio Free, the Freshdesk free program). Shopify-first stores often look at Gorgias because order data sits next to the ticket. Small teams that just need a shared inbox (email, live chat, Facebook) can look at Helpwise, priced per user. Marketplace sellers look at eDesk. Larger teams look at Zendesk or Richpanel. Always compare current pricing on each vendor site.
How much is a chargeback fee?
It depends on the processor. Stripe lists a $15 dispute fee plus a $15 counter fee if you contest, which is refunded if you win. Check your own processor for its current fee.
Are the links affiliate links?
Some are. Links to vendors with an approved affiliate program are marked sponsored and StoreVetted may earn a commission at no cost to you. Recommendations follow fixed rules based on your inputs.
What share of lost and damaged claims can I recover?
It depends on insurance and timing. USPS pays only on insured mail and never more than actual value (USPS); UPS wants the claim within 60 days of the scheduled delivery (UPS); FedEx within 60 days for damage and nine months for loss (FedEx). Use your own claims history for the percentage.
What does a claim cost per order?
Total monthly claims cost ÷ orders shipped. With the default example numbers: $1,068 ÷ 1,000 orders = $1.07 per order.