1. Home
  2. Tools
  3. Store credit vs refund

Does offering store credit actually keep the cash?

Enter the return requests, the average amount, the share of customers who will accept credit, and how much of that credit you expect will later be spent. The acceptance and redemption defaults are examples, not a typical take-up rate.

Some links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Drafted with AI, checked by a human. How we earn.

  • Your own numbers
  • Every formula shown
  • Runs in your browser
Illustration of a payments and reserves desk

Refunds and credit

Examples, not a take-up rate

Every default below is an example, not a benchmark. Use the volume from your own returns queue. Some markets require a cash refund for certain returns — this form does not decide that for you.

1The queue
2Who accepts credit, and who later spends it

The 40% and 70% figures are examples. Replace them with the take-up and redemption you actually see, or leave them as a what-if.

3Payment fees you do not get back on a cash refund

The 2.9% + 0.30 figures are examples of a card-processing shape, not a quoted Shopify or card-network rate. Type the amount you actually do not recover when you refund.

How the math works

Refunding everyone costs the full amount plus the unrecoverable payment fees you typed. On the mixed path, only the customers who refuse credit are refunded in cash, with those fees attached. Store credit issued is a liability. Later redemptions use the redemption rate you typed. Unredeemed credit is still a liability in this model; it is not treated as income.

For the policy choice, not just the arithmetic, see store credit versus refund after the holidays. This calculator does not invent a take-up rate and is not consumer-law advice.

See a Shopify gift-card balance checker

FAQ

Can I assume most customers will accept store credit?

No. Type the share you actually see, or leave the example as a what-if. Some customers will insist on a cash refund, and some markets require one.

Why is unredeemed credit not counted as a saving?

Because it is still a liability until it is redeemed, expires, or is treated under the rules that apply to you. The result shows it as unredeemed, not as income.

Are the 2.9% and 0.30 fee figures official?

No. They are an example of a percentage-plus-fixed fee so the form can run. Replace them with the amount you actually do not recover when you refund a payment.

Is this a gift-card breakage calculator?

No. For outstanding gift-card balances, use the gift-card liability estimator. This tool only compares a cash refund with store credit on a returns batch.