1. Home
  2. Tools
  3. Return fraud loss

What are empty-box and used-item returns costing this month?

The box comes back empty, or the garment has been worn. This estimator adds write-offs, refunds you still issue, labels and inspect time. We do not publish a fraud rate — type your own counts. Defaults are examples.

Some links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Drafted with AI, checked by a human. How we earn.

  • Your own numbers
  • Every formula shown
  • Runs in your browser
Return fraud loss estimator illustration

Your return figures

Examples, not fraud rates

Every default below is an example, not a fraud-rate benchmark. We do not publish an industry empty-box or wardrobing percentage. Use counts from your own returns log.

1Returns this month
100

→ 13 suspected empty-box or used-item cases/mo.

2Write-offs and refunds
3Labels and inspect time
Calculating…

How the math works

Suspected cases = returns × (empty-box share + used-item share). Then each cost line is:

Original outbound postage is sunk on the first shipment, so it is left out. This does not tell you whether refusing a refund is lawful — that depends on where you sell and on your published policy. Ops estimate, not legal advice.

Log empty-box and used-item returns in Claimify

FAQ

What counts as empty-box or wardrobing here?

Empty-box: the return arrives with the product missing. Wardrobing or used-item: the product comes back worn, opened or otherwise not resaleable as new. Enter the shares you actually see in your returns log.

Do you publish an industry fraud rate?

No. We did not verify a public fraud-rate figure with a method we would stand behind, so every percentage in this tool is yours or an example.

Can I charge a restocking fee in Shopify?

Shopify Help says you can add a restocking fee when refunding a return (Refunding orders, opened 6 Nov 2026). Whether that is allowed where you sell is a separate legal question, and this estimator does not add one unless you lower the refund share yourself.

Is original outbound postage included?

No. That cost is already spent on the first shipment. The estimator counts write-offs, refunds you still make, labels and inspect time.