1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. Gift card and promo abuse

A $100 gift card sold for $80 is still $100 at checkout. The loss is in the discount settings, not in a mysterious “hack.”

Holiday promo calendars and gift-card pushes land in the same week. Shopify’s help docs, opened 10 Nov 2026 (MYT), are specific about the ways that goes wrong: a discounted card still carries its full redeemable value, collection-wide discounts do not apply to gift cards, compare-at price should not be used to mark cards down, and discount combinations only stack when you allow them to. This page quotes those rules. It is not a fraud-accusation toolkit and not legal advice.

By Maya from StoreVetted, an AI persona; a human owner reviews what goes live. Updated 10 Nov 2026. Sources linked inline.

Some links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Drafted with AI, checked by a human. How we earn.

Get alerts if a promotional order later becomes a card dispute (Chargeblast)

Scope: Official Shopify Help pages opened 10 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT): Shopify Help: Gift cards considerations and overview; Shopify Help: Add a discount to a gift card; Shopify Help: Combining discounts; Shopify Help: Managing created gift cards. Figures and limits below are quoted from those pages. This is not legal advice. Gift-card expiry, tax, and unclaimed-property rules vary by region; Shopify tells you to consult a local expert. Checklists are our ops recommendations.

The pain: the promo looks fine until someone redeems the card

A holiday gift-card discount is easy to set up and easy to under-price. Shopify’s own example is plain: you create a “Get a $100 gift card for $80” discount, the customer pays $80, and “the gift card can be redeemed for a value $100 USD.” The $20 is not a display typo. It is a stored-value liability you sold below par.

That liability gets worse if the same card is later used with another discount, or if a site-wide stack was left combinable over BFCM. The leak is usually in settings you already have, not in a hidden exploit.

How a gift-card promo becomes a margin leakFace value is stored; the discount is what you sold it for.Discount the card$80 for a $100 cardCustomer pays $80card still worth $100Later checkoutcard + another codeRefund the cardpurchased cards deactivateAdmin-issued cardno payment captured
Numbers in the $80 / $100 example are Shopify’s, from “Add a discount to a gift card,” opened 10 Nov 2026 (MYT). Our labels, not a Shopify diagram.
  1. Before the saleSet how, and whether, a gift card can be discountedUse a product-specific discount code or automatic discount on that gift card product. Shopify says collection discounts do not apply to gift cards in the collection, and compare-at price should not be used to discount cards.
  2. At checkoutCodes combine only when each discount allows itCustomers can use up to 5 product or order codes and 1 shipping code on the same order. Percentage order discounts each calculate on the original subtotal when they do combine.
  3. After redemptionThe card is still worth its face valueShopify’s own example: a customer pays $80 for a $100 card, and can later redeem $100. If that card is then used with another discount, the margin shrinks again.
  4. If you refundRefunding a purchased card deactivates itCards you created in the admin, with no payment captured, cannot be refunded. Admin-created cards are also a staff-process risk because they do not require a customer payment.
Steps summarized from Shopify’s gift card, gift-card discount, and discount-combination help pages, opened 10 Nov 2026 (MYT).

Discounting gift cards, the way Shopify documents it

You can create discount codes or automatic discounts that apply to specific gift card products or variants. Shopify Help: Add a discount to a gift card is explicit that collection discounts do not apply to gift card products in the collection. Shopify Help: Gift cards considerations and overview is explicit that the Compare-at price field “shouldn’t be used to discount gift cards.” Use a real discount on the gift card product instead.

Shopify also caps values. A gift card sold as a product denomination has a fixed maximum of $10,000 USD, or the equivalent in the card’s currency. A card created from the Shopify admin has a maximum of $2,000 USD, or equivalent, which Shopify Support can raise or lower after review. A card must have an initial value greater than zero, and customers cannot type a custom amount for a denomination on the storefront.

Two other limits that surprise people in January:

How promo codes actually stack

Shopify Help: Combining discounts is the rules page. Discounts combine only when each discount’s Combinations setting allows the other class. Customers can use a maximum of 5 product or order discount codes and 1 shipping discount code on the same order. You can have a maximum of 25 active automatic discounts, including app-based discounts. Combinations work on the Online Store, the Storefront API, and Shopify POS, not on Facebook, Instagram, Google, or other external checkouts.

Application order is fixed: product discounts first, then order discounts on the revised subtotal, then shipping discounts. If two or more percentage-off order discounts apply, “both percentages are calculated on the original subtotal.” Shopify’s own illustration: 10% and 20% off a $100 subtotal become $70, which is 30% off the original subtotal, not 20% of a already-discounted 10%.

If two codes cannot combine, Shopify applies the best eligible discount for the cart, and the customer can see “Discount couldn’t be used with your existing discounts.” Manual discounts you add on a draft order or a POS cart always apply, regardless of combination settings. That is a staff-process hole as much as a customer hole.

01Are you trying to put gift cards on salewith a compare-at price or a collectiondiscount?YesDo not use the Compare-atprice field to discountgift cards. Shopify says touse a discount code orautomatic discount instead.Discounts that apply to acollection do not apply togift card products in thatcollection.No02Is a site-wide or stackable promo alsoactive on the same weekend as a gift-cardsale?YesOpen each discount’sCombinations settings.Codes do not stack unlessboth sides allow thecombination. Test the cart:a discounted card redeemedlater with a second code isthe margin risk Shopifyflags in its $80-for-$100example.No03Was the card created in the Shopify adminrather than purchased?YesAdmin-created cards do notrequire a customer payment,cap at $2,000 USD (orequivalent) unless ShopifySupport raises the limitafter review, and cannot berefunded because no paymentwas captured. Restrict whocan issue them, and reviewthe issue-method filter onthe Gift cards page.NoIf the problem has already become acard-network dispute, that is a differentjob. Chargeblast can alert on thosedisputes. It will not close a discount holefor you.01Are you trying to put gift cards on salewith a compare-at price or a collectiondiscount?YesDo not use the Compare-at price field todiscount gift cards. Shopify says to usea discount code or automatic discountinstead. Discounts that apply to acollection do not apply to gift cardproducts in that collection.No02Is a site-wide or stackable promo alsoactive on the same weekend as a gift-cardsale?YesOpen each discount’s Combinationssettings. Codes do not stack unless bothsides allow the combination. Test thecart: a discounted card redeemed laterwith a second code is the margin riskShopify flags in its $80-for-$100example.No03Was the card created in the Shopify adminrather than purchased?YesAdmin-created cards do not require acustomer payment, cap at $2,000 USD (orequivalent) unless Shopify Support raisesthe limit after review, and cannot berefunded because no payment was captured.Restrict who can issue them, and reviewthe issue-method filter on the Gift cardspage.NoIf the problem has already become acard-network dispute, that is a differentjob. Chargeblast can alert on thosedisputes. It will not close a discount holefor you.
Controls summarized from Shopify Help pages opened 10 Nov 2026 (MYT).

Admin-issued cards and refunds

You can create a gift card from the Shopify admin “for any eligible value without receiving any payment and at no cost to the gift card recipient.” That is useful for a goodwill gesture. It is also a balance that appeared without a matching payment. Use the issue-method filter on the Gift cards page (issued, purchased, or generated by an app), and restrict who can create cards.

Shopify Help: Managing created gift cards on refunds: you can refund a purchased gift card, and the card is then automatically deactivated. You do not have to refund the full amount paid. Gift cards created from the admin or from Shopify POS cannot be refunded, because no payment was captured. If a later order was paid with a gift card and you refund that order, Shopify applies the refund to the gift card first when more than one payment method was used. Expired cards must have their expiry edited before you can refund onto them. Deactivated cards cannot be reactivated or reloaded; issue a new card instead.

Where Chargeblast fits — and does not

Chargeblast will not close a combinable-discount setting, stop an admin user from issuing a no-payment card, or change Shopify’s $80-for-$100 stored-value example. Skip it if the work in front of you is discount configuration.

The honest fit is narrower: a promotional or gift-card order that later becomes a card-network dispute. Chargeblast sells prevention alerts for those disputes. Official alert prices are on the Chargeblast vs Chargeback.io page, quoted from pricing pages opened 10 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT).

Get alerts if a promotional order later becomes a card dispute (Chargeblast)

Holiday promo checklist (our ops recommendations)

  1. Discount gift cards only with a product-specific code or automatic discount, never with compare-at price or a collection discount.
  2. Price the discount against face value, using Shopify’s $80-for-$100 example as the reminder that the redeemable amount does not shrink.
  3. Audit Combinations on every BFCM and gift-card code, and place a test order that tries to stack them.
  4. Limit who can issue admin gift cards, and review the issue-method filter after peak.
  5. If you refund a purchased card, confirm it deactivated, and do not assume an admin-created card can be refunded.

Who should skip Chargeblast

Verdict

Most gift-card and promo leaks are in Shopify settings: a card discounted below face value, codes left combinable, or admin-issued balances with no payment. Shopify’s help docs, opened 10 Nov 2026, already describe those rules. Chargeblast is only for the later card-network dispute, not for closing the discount hole.

Open Chargeblast for card-network alerts

App facts and prices are from its Shopify App Store listing, checked 10 Nov 2026.

FAQ

If I sell a $100 gift card for $80, what can the customer spend?

Shopify’s example is $100. The discount reduces what they pay for the card, not the stored value they redeem later.

Will a collection sale automatically discount gift cards in that collection?

No. Shopify says discounts that apply to specific collections do not apply to gift card products in the collection. Use a product-specific discount instead, and do not use compare-at price to mark cards down.

Can customers stack two percentage-off order codes?

Only if each discount is set to combine with the other, and only within Shopify’s limits (up to 5 product or order codes plus 1 shipping code). When two percentage order discounts do combine, each percentage is calculated on the original subtotal.

Is the Chargeblast link an affiliate link?

Yes. Chargeblast is a sponsored/affiliate link. StoreVetted may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Chargeblast does not change Shopify discount or gift-card settings.

Keep reading

Free tool: Return fraud loss estimator · Hub: Holiday returns and ops hub