Ops template, not law. No fraud rates, legal thresholds or restocking-fee limits are claimed here; those vary by country and we did not verify them. Check your local consumer law before refusing a refund. Not legal advice.
The post-BFCM returns pile
- Refund-on-scan: if refunds fire when the return label is scanned, an empty box gets paid out before anyone opens it.
- Wardrobing: worn once for an event, returned "unworn". Common in occasion wear; in beauty it's opened, used and resealed product.
- No receipt photo, no case: if nobody photographed the parcel on arrival, it's your word against the customer's.
- Refusal has a cost: a refused refund can become a card dispute, so the decision needs evidence behind it.
How each one looks in the ticket
| Pattern | What you see | First check |
|---|---|---|
| Empty box | Return arrives sealed but empty or with filler; customer insists the item was inside | Weight on the return label vs the outbound weight; photo of the parcel unopened |
| Swap / substitution | A cheaper, older or different item comes back | SKU, tag, batch or serial vs what you shipped |
| Wardrobing | Item worn: odour, makeup, deodorant, stretched seams, tags removed or re-attached | Photos of tags, seams, underarms; compare to your tag/seal style |
| Used beauty | Seal broken, product level down, swatched | Seal/shrink-wrap and fill level photos |
| Genuine wrong item | Customer says you sent the wrong thing | Your error until shown otherwise — see wrong item / mis-pick |
Refund decision matrix (ops template, not law)
| Evidence on receipt | Suggested decision | Shopify step |
|---|---|---|
| Item back, resaleable, tags/seal intact | Full refund per your policy | Refund after inspection (Shopify Help: Refunding orders) |
| Item back, minor wear or missing tag, not resaleable as new | Partial refund, only if your published policy says so and local law allows | Partial refund; Shopify lets you add a restocking fee when refunding (Shopify Help: Refunding orders) |
| Clearly worn/used against a stated "unworn, tags on" policy | Offer return of the item to the customer or partial refund; escalate to a lead | Hold the refund; note photos on the order timeline |
| Empty box or substituted item, weight mismatch documented | Don't refund yet; open a carrier investigation and ask the customer for their drop-off proof | Keep the return open until resolved |
| Evidence unclear | Refund. A weak refusal costs more than the item | Refund; tag the customer for review |
Prevention checklist
- Turn off refund-on-scan for high-value apparel and beauty; refund after inspection.
- Record outbound weight per order and compare with the inbound return label weight.
- Unbox returns on camera at a fixed bench, label visible, before cutting tape.
- Branded, hard-to-reattach tags on occasion wear (a large swing tag on a visible spot discourages wearing).
- Tamper seals / shrink-wrap on beauty, with your batch or a serial noted per order where practical.
- Clear policy wording: "unworn, unwashed, original tags attached; beauty unopened". This is advice for clarity, not a statement of legal force; your local consumer law may override it.
- Ask customers to keep drop-off receipts in the return instructions.
- Tag repeat returners and review them weekly; don't auto-ban on one case.
Pasteable macro (adapt)
Hi [first name], Thanks for sending back order [number]. When we opened the return on [date], we found [the parcel was empty / a different item / the item shows signs of wear: describe]. Photos are attached. The parcel weighed [x] on arrival; the original shipment weighed [y]. Could you reply with your drop-off receipt and any photos you took when packing? We've also opened an investigation with [carrier]. As soon as we have that, we'll come back to you with the next step: [full refund / partial refund of [amount] per our returns policy / returning the item to you]. Thanks, [name]
Gorgias keeps the macro, order data, photos and tags in one ticket, so the evidence is already in one place if a dispute arrives.
Build return-fraud macros in Gorgias
When it turns into a chargeback
If you refuse or part-refund and the customer disputes with their bank, your response rests on what you saved: policy text shown at checkout, receipt photos/video, weights, tracking and the ticket thread. We did not open a card-network page for this guide, so we don't cite reason codes here. See Visa 13.1 evidence and Black Friday chargebacks (UK). If you want claims and their photos logged in one place, Claimify keeps a record per claim.
Log return claims with photos (Claimify)
Related guides
- Customer received wrong item
- Visa 13.1 chargeback evidence
- Black Friday chargebacks (UK)
- Reduce WISMO tickets on Black Friday
Who should skip this
- Low-AOV stores where a "returnless refund" is cheaper than inspection.
- Stores whose 3PL already inspects and photographs returns: use only the matrix and macro.
- Skip the tools if you see only a few suspicious returns a season.
Verdict
Inspect before you refund, film the unboxing, compare weights, and refuse only with documented evidence and a clear policy. When in doubt, refund and flag the customer. Ops template, not law.
See Gorgias for Shopify return macros
Shopify mechanics from Shopify Help (Returns and exchanges; Refunding orders incl. restocking fee), opened 6 Nov 2026. Everything else is an ops checklist/template, not law. Gorgias and Claimify are affiliate links.