Not legal advice. We summarise Afterpay merchant/developer docs and Klarna Partner Portal dispute docs for ops planning. Afterpay and Klarna decide outcomes. We do not invent response windows — every day-count below is quoted from a linked official page.
The pain: BNPL dispute, short clock, thin tracking
- Afterpay AU: non-receipt claims land in Business Hub under Disputes. You get three choices: accept (refund), challenge with an explanation and evidence, or mark that you already refunded (Afterpay AU: Handling disputes in the Business Hub).
- Miss Afterpay's 13-day window and Afterpay refunds the customer and reverses the amount from you (Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub, Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes).
- Klarna Flow 2026: one request, one response, PDF evidence only. Standard deadline is 21 calendar days from Klarna's request; miss it and you lose (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal).
- Tracking link alone fails on Klarna. Klarna says a link to online tracking is not sufficient — you must attach POD that meets its Merchant Protection Program rules (Klarna Docs: Disputes Evidence Guidelines).
- Same order can still hit a card chargeback later. See Visa 13.1 evidence and Black Friday chargebacks (UK).
Afterpay (AU): Business Hub merchant response
From the Afterpay AU: Handling disputes in the Business Hub and the Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub / Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes:
- Reason today: Afterpay supports only
product_not_receivedas a dispute reason (Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes). The AU merchant help frames it as a claim of non-receipt of goods. - Where: log in to Business Hub → Disputes. Email notifies you of a new dispute; open "Review Detail" (Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub).
- Three responses (Afterpay AU: Handling disputes in the Business Hub):
- Accept the dispute — use if you do not have the order / will not fulfil; Afterpay processes a refund for the customer.
- Challenge the dispute — update the customer with an explanation and provide evidence. Case Document text is capped at 500 characters (longer text errors).
- I've already refunded this customer — if a refund is already processed, no further action.
- Customer window: customers may raise a dispute only from 7 days after payment is captured; after 120 days they can no longer raise one. They are prompted to contact you first (Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub).
- Merchant evidence window: 13 days from notification to final evidence submission (Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes). If you accept, or do not respond within 13 days, Afterpay refunds the customer and initiates a reversal with you (Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub).
- After you challenge: the customer can accept or reject your response, or cancel if the order arrives. If they reject, Afterpay adjudicates on the available evidence; Afterpay's decision window after evidence is 30 days (Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes, Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub).
- Closing reasons shown to merchants include
merchant_accepted,evidence_accepted,evidence_rejected,deadline_expired,customer_cancelled(Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes). Afterpay "only gathers funds from the merchant after the merchant loses the dispute" (Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes).
Evidence list gap (sourced): the AU Business Hub help page says to provide evidence "such as, but not limited to:" and then does not list examples on the live page we opened 6 Nov 2026. We do not invent Afterpay's evidence bullets. Use carrier delivery proof, order/refund records and customer messages as your pack, and follow whatever the case UI asks for.
Klarna: Disputes Flow 2026 (Partner Portal)
From the Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal and Klarna Docs: Disputes Evidence Guidelines (opened 6 Nov 2026). Klarna is moving Partner Portal–only merchants to Flow 2026 at the beginning of November 2026; check which sidebar heading your case sits under (Flow 2026 NEW vs Flow 2020 LEGACY).
- Not-received reason name: Flow 2026 uses Products or services not received (was "Goods not received" in Flow 2020) (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal).
- Standard merchant deadline: 21 calendar days after Klarna sends its request (same time of day). Weekends and public holidays count. Purchase unauthorized: 7 calendar days; Purchase high-risk: 4 (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal).
- One chance: after Submit you cannot edit, add files or send a second response; Klarna will not ask follow-ups (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal).
- PDF only, up to 7.3 MB per file; explanation up to 5,000 characters. Propose an optional partial refund in the same response (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal).
- Klarna decision: within 30 calendar days after your response (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal).
- Until 1 March 2027: Klarna says nothing is charged or held while a dispute is open; you are charged if you lose, accept the loss, Klarna accepts your partial refund, or you refund the order (fees still follow your Klarna agreement) (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal).
- Mandatory POD for not received: must meet Klarna's Merchant Protection Program (MPP) sections 1.1 or 1.3 for the order type/value; "a link to online tracking is not sufficient. An attachment must be provided" (Klarna Docs: Disputes Evidence Guidelines). Flow 2026 evidence table for this reason: carrier, tracking number, shipping date, delivery date, proof of delivery (signature or photo), delivery address (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal).
Shopify Help note (Klarna on Shopify Payments)
Per Shopify Help: Klarna for Shopify Payments: current Klarna-for-Shopify-Payments disputes are managed from the Shopify admin; "Klarna disputes follow Klarna's dispute process, and Klarna decides the outcome." A separate legacy path applies only if your store is in Austria, Germany or Sweden, you activated Klarna on or before 26 Sep 2025, and the customer opened the dispute before that date — then Klarna emails you and Shopify Help says you have 7 days to respond. Use the due date on your case; do not assume the legacy 7-day email window for current Flow 2026 / admin disputes.
Afterpay vs Klarna: sourced comparison
| Topic | Afterpay (AU / Business Hub) | Klarna (Flow 2026 Partner Portal) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary not-received label | product_not_received / Goods Not Received (Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes, Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub) | Products or services not received (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal) |
| Customer open window | From 7 days after capture; closes after 120 days (Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub) | Customer time with merchant first; Klarna escalates when unresolved (exact pre-escalation days not quoted here — see portal) (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal) |
| Merchant response window | 13 days from notification (Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes, Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub) | 21 calendar days standard; 7 unauthorized; 4 high-risk (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal) |
| If you miss it | Refund to customer + reversal from merchant (Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub); closing reason deadline_expired (Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes) | Dispute closed in customer's favour; chargeback of disputed amount + fee per agreement (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal) |
| Response format | Business Hub challenge + supporting docs; Case Document ≤500 characters (Afterpay AU: Handling disputes in the Business Hub) | One or more PDFs (≤7.3 MB each) + optional ≤5,000-character reply; one Submit (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal) |
| Decision after evidence | Up to 30 days (Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes); customer can reject → Afterpay adjudicates (Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub) | Within 30 calendar days; no follow-up rounds in Flow 2026 (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal) |
| Already refunded | Explicit third option: mark refunded (Afterpay AU: Handling disputes in the Business Hub) | Refund the order in full (or accept loss / respond with refund proof) (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal) |
| Published POD bullet list | Not listed on the AU help page we opened (gap noted above) | Yes — carrier, tracking, ship/delivery dates, POD signature/photo, address; MPP attachment required (Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal, Klarna Docs: Disputes Evidence Guidelines) |
Sources: Afterpay AU: Handling disputes in the Business Hub; Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub; Afterpay Online Developer: Disputes; Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal; Klarna Docs: Disputes Evidence Guidelines. All opened 6 Nov 2026. Fee dollar amounts are under your merchant agreement — we left unpublished fee tables out.
Evidence checklist (ops pack)
Klarna — Products or services not received (publishable list from Klarna Docs: Disputes Flow 2026 in Klarna Partner Portal / Klarna Docs: Disputes Evidence Guidelines):
- Carrier name and tracking number
- Shipping date and delivery date
- Proof of delivery (signature or photo) as a PDF attachment — not a tracking URL alone
- Delivery address matching the approved checkout address
- Order/reference number and a short timeline summary at the top of your explanation
- Customer messages / "I got it" threads when you have them
Afterpay — product_not_received (no official bullet list on the AU page): put the same delivery and refund artefacts into Business Hub supporting documentation, keep the Case Document explanation ≤500 characters, and use the "already refunded" option when that is true (Afterpay AU: Handling disputes in the Business Hub, Afterpay Online Developer: Manage disputes in the Business Hub).
Always keep ready:
- Carrier portal screenshot or PDF showing Delivered (date + address)
- Shopify/fulfilment timeline and tracking PDF
- Refund ID, amount and date if you already refunded
- Support chat / email with the buyer
- Return/warehouse receipt if the claim is really about a return (Klarna "Refund not processed" has its own mandatory evidence — see Klarna Docs: Disputes Evidence Guidelines)
Related delivery-dispute spines: PayPal INR (Australia) · Visa 13.1 evidence.
Tools when volume outgrows a checklist
Chargeback.io automates chargeback/dispute responses and alerts for Shopify stores — useful when Afterpay/Klarna cases sit next to card chargebacks and you cannot hand-build every pack.
Chargeblast focuses on dispute alerts so you can refund before an inquiry becomes a fee-bearing chargeback.
See Chargeblast dispute alerts
Disputifier is another Shopify chargeback-automation option.
Many BNPL "not received" cases start as a delivery claim in support. Claimify, a Shopify app, logs not-received, lost and damaged claims with photos and outcomes so the record exists before Afterpay or Klarna asks. If payout holds or reserves show up after a dispute spike, see Shopify Payments reserve: how to remove.
Log not-received claims before they become BNPL disputes (Claimify)
Who should skip this playbook (or the tools)
- Low volume: a few Afterpay/Klarna disputes a year is a checklist job — open the portal the day the email lands, submit POD, done.
- Already refunded: use Afterpay's "already refunded" option or Klarna's refund-the-order path; do not burn the evidence window building a challenge you do not need.
- No tracking / untracked postage: fighting product_not_received without delivery status rarely works; fix fulfilment first.
- Card-network disputes only: this page is BNPL portal flow. For Visa 13.1 use the Visa evidence guide.
- Not on Shopify: Disputifier, Claimify and most Chargeback.io Shopify workflows assume Shopify admin data.
Not legal advice. Re-check the linked Afterpay and Klarna pages before you change policy — portals and Flow 2026 migration dates move.
Verdict
For Afterpay AU, treat every Goods Not Received / product_not_received case as a 13-day Business Hub job: accept, challenge (≤500-character Case Document + supporting docs), or mark already refunded — miss it and Afterpay refunds the buyer and reverses you. For Klarna Flow 2026, you get one PDF response within 21 calendar days (standard); attach real POD (not a tracking link). Keep refund and delivery artefacts ready; automate only when BNPL volume sits next to card chargebacks (Chargeback.io / Chargeblast / Disputifier). Not legal advice.
Catch card disputes as alerts (Chargeblast)
Facts from Afterpay AU Business Hub help, Afterpay Online Developer dispute docs, Klarna Disputes Flow 2026 / Evidence Guidelines, and Shopify Help Klarna pages, opened 6 Nov 2026. Chargeback.io, Chargeblast and Disputifier are third-party (affiliate links); Claimify link is an affiliate link. Not legal advice.