Not legal advice. We summarise public ACCC and business.gov.au pages for overseas seller ops. Whether ACL applies to a given order, and what remedy is owed, depends on the facts, product and how you offer sales into Australia. Get Australian legal advice for your store. Statutory consumer guarantees cannot be removed by your returns policy.
Why overseas sellers get Australian refund tickets wrong
- "We're not in Australia, so ACL doesn't apply." ACCC states the opposite for direct sales: when an overseas online business provides goods or services directly to consumers in Australia, it must follow the Australian Consumer Law, including consumer guarantees (ACCC: Selling online; ACCC: Buying online; ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business)). business.gov.au likewise says all businesses selling goods and services in Australia must comply, including overseas businesses (business.gov.au: Australian Consumer Law and your business).
- UK/EU "14-day cooling-off" macros pasted onto AU orders. ACL consumer guarantees are not a statutory change-of-mind cancellation period. Change of mind is not a guarantee remedy (ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel). Do not invent a fixed day count and call it ACL.
- One "no refunds after 30 days" policy for everything. Fault claims under consumer guarantees are not the same as a voluntary change-of-mind window. ACCC says businesses cannot take away guarantee rights with "no refunds" or "no refunds after X days" wording (ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business); ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel).
- "Contact the manufacturer / dropshipper." The seller who sold to the consumer must help. ACCC and business.gov.au say you must not refuse help by sending the buyer to the manufacturer or importer (ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel; business.gov.au: Australian Consumer Law and your business).
- Treating every "refund" ticket as chargeback bait or as change-of-mind. Major failure → buyer chooses refund or replacement. Minor failure → free repair first (refund/replacement only if you can't or won't fix in a reasonable time) (ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel).
When ACL applies to overseas / foreign online stores
ACCC (selling online / buying online / consumer guarantees):
- Applies: online business based overseas that provides goods or services directly to consumers in Australia — must follow ACL, including consumer guarantees (ACCC: Selling online; ACCC: Buying online; ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business)).
- business.gov.au: "All businesses selling goods and services in Australia must comply with the ACL. This includes businesses that are overseas." (business.gov.au: Australian Consumer Law and your business)
- Does not cover the consumer (ACCC examples) when the business does not directly offer products/services in Australia — e.g. goods sent to an overseas address first, then forwarded to Australia; or the transaction occurred entirely overseas (consumer also overseas) (ACCC: Selling online; ACCC: Buying online).
- Practical note (ACCC): remedies can be hard to obtain from some overseas sellers, and Australian consumer agencies' help can be limited — that does not mean the guarantees do not apply when you sell directly into Australia (ACCC: Selling online).
Jurisdiction and "carrying on business in Australia" can be fact-specific (courts have applied ACL to some overseas digital sellers). This page does not decide your case. Not legal advice.
Major failure vs minor failure vs change of mind (sourced)
| Topic | Major problem (goods) | Minor problem (goods) | Change of mind | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Failure so serious that remedy choice sits with the consumer (ACCC "major problem") | Problem that must be fixed/repaired free; seller usually chooses repair over refund | Buyer got what they asked for but no longer wants it / found cheaper / no use | ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel |
| ACCC tests (goods) | Unsafe; very different from description or sample; one serious or several smaller problems that would stop someone buying if known beforehand; or can't be used for normal / disclosed purpose and can't easily be fixed within a reasonable time | Not meeting that major threshold — still a consumer-guarantee issue that needs a free fix | Not a consumer-guarantee failure | ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel |
| Buyer's remedy | Choose refund or replacement of the same type (may also keep goods and seek compensation for drop in value; damages/loss in some cases) | Seller must fix/repair for free. Seller need not offer refund/replacement (may choose to). If seller can't or won't within a reasonable time, buyer can get repair elsewhere (seller pays reasonable cost), refund or replacement, or keep goods with compensation for drop in value | No ACL guarantee remedy. If you publish a change-of-mind policy, you must follow it; you may set conditions (days, tags, packaging) on that policy only | ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel; ACCC: Contacting a business to fix a problem; business.gov.au: Australian Consumer Law and your business |
| Refund amount / form | Full amount paid; must not deduct for use the consumer already had; same payment form unless both agree otherwise | If refund becomes available (e.g. repair fails / refused): follow ACCC refund rules for that remedy path | Only per your published policy | ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel |
| Fixed day clock? | No ACCC statutory "refund within N days" clock like UK CCR. Act without undue delay; repair "reasonable time" depends on the product | Same — ACCC ties failed-repair escalation to "reasonable amount of time," not a published universal day count | Only the days you state in a voluntary policy | ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel |
| Return shipping | Buyer returns goods that can be posted or easily returned. Seller pays shipping/collection for large, heavy or hard-to-remove items (e.g. widescreen TVs, beds, installed appliances) within a reasonable time. If the business confirms a problem, it must reimburse reasonable return costs the consumer already paid (keep postage receipts). If no problem, seller may charge collection/inspection costs only after giving a reasonable estimate beforehand | Per your change-of-mind policy (ACL does not force free returns for mind-change) | ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel | |
| Policy traps | Illegal to rely on "no refunds" / "no refunds or exchanges on sale items" to deny guarantee remedies. Change-of-mind conditions (days, sale items, packaging) must not be applied to major/minor guarantee claims | You may say "no refunds for change of mind" if that matches policy — never for guarantee failures | ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel; ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business); ACCC: Contacting a business to fix a problem; business.gov.au: Australian Consumer Law and your business | |
| Manufacturer punt | Seller must not tell the consumer to take the problem to the manufacturer/importer instead of helping. After you remedy, you may seek manufacturer reimbursement under ACL where applicable | ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel; business.gov.au: Australian Consumer Law and your business | ||
Guarantees also cover acceptable quality, fit for purpose, match description / sample, express warranties, and (for manufacturers/importers) spare parts and repair facilities for a reasonable time — see ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business). Acceptable quality has no set rule for how long goods must last; durability depends on type, price, claims and use (ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business)). Thresholds for "consumer" (e.g. under $100,000 including GST, or normally personal/household) are summarised on business.gov.au: Australian Consumer Law and your business and ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business) — confirm for B2B edge cases.
Overseas seller checklist (AU consumer tickets)
- Tag routes:
acl-major,acl-minor,change-of-mind,acl-out-of-scope(forwarded-from-overseas-address / entirely-overseas transaction per ACCC examples). Never auto-apply one "14-day returns" tag to AU fault tickets. - Confirm direct AU sale: AU ship-to address, AU-facing offer, AUD/AU shipping zone, AU marketing. If the order was ship-to overseas then privately forwarded, ACCC says the consumer may not be covered — still be careful with misleading replies (ACCC: Selling online).
- Ask major vs minor facts: safety, mismatch to description, whether a reasonable buyer would have purchased knowing the fault, whether purpose fails and is not easily fixable in a reasonable time (ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel).
- Major path: offer buyer choice of full refund or same-type replacement; no use-deduction; same payment method unless they agree otherwise (ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel).
- Minor path: offer free repair/fix with a clear reasonable timeline for that SKU. If you cannot meet it, escalate to refund/replacement options (ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel).
- Return logistics: easy-post items — buyer returns, then reimburse reasonable postage if fault confirmed. Bulky/installed — arrange collection/pay shipping within a reasonable time (ACCC: Repair, replace, refund, cancel).
- Policy copy: state consumer guarantees separately from any voluntary change-of-mind window. Ban "no refunds" / "contact manufacturer only" language for faults (ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business); business.gov.au: Australian Consumer Law and your business).
- Helpdesk: macros with merge fields for order number, fault summary, major/minor assessment, remedy offered, return address or collection window, and postage-reimbursement rule. Gorgias is the affiliate we link for macros and tags — it does not make you ACL-compliant.
Build major vs minor ACL macros in Gorgias
Pasteable first reply (adapt — not a legal form)
Thanks for contacting us about order [number]. We sell to customers in Australia and handle Australian Consumer Law consumer-guarantee claims on the product we sold you (we will not send you only to the manufacturer). Please reply with: (1) what is wrong, (2) when you first noticed it, (3) photos/video if useful, and (4) whether you believe this is a major failure (e.g. unsafe, significantly not as described, or cannot be used for its purpose and not easily fixed) or a minor issue that repair can fix. If it is a major failure under the consumer guarantees, you can choose a full refund or a replacement. If it is a minor failure, we will repair or fix it free of charge within a reasonable time for this product; if we cannot, we will discuss refund or replacement options. For returns: [easy-post instructions OR collection plan for bulky goods]. If we confirm a problem, we will reimburse reasonable return postage you paid (please keep the receipt). Change-of-mind returns follow our published policy at [link] and are separate from guarantee rights. This message is an ops reply, not legal advice.
Replace brackets from the order and your counsel-approved policy. Do not promise a fixed "refund in N days" unless your counsel and payment rails support that SLA — ACCC pages we opened do not publish a universal ACL refund day count. Not legal advice.
Where Gorgias helps (and where it doesn't)
AU ACL tickets fail when agents paste EU/UK cooling-off scripts or "contact the supplier" macros. A helpdesk with tags, rules and saved replies keeps major, minor and change-of-mind on separate tracks so you do not deny a guarantee remedy with a mind-change policy.
See Gorgias for Shopify support
Gorgias does not interpret Australian law, decide major vs minor failure, or replace legal review of your AU-facing policy.
Related guides
- UK CRA / CCR refund timeline — different regime; do not reuse UK day clocks on AU tickets.
- PayPal item not received (seller, Australia) — payment-platform disputes that often sit beside ACL claims.
- Supplements held at customs (Australia) — AU border holds that trigger WISMO and refund pressure.
- GPSR Shopify compliance — EU product-safety ops (separate from ACL guarantees).
Who should skip this
- Stores that never offer or ship to Australia — and do not market to AU consumers; ACCC's "directly offer in Australia" line is the threshold to discuss with counsel (ACCC: Selling online).
- Pure change-of-mind policy design with no fault claims — still separate guarantee language from mind-change rules so you do not mislead (ACCC: Contacting a business to fix a problem).
- Services-only, financial products, or pre-2011 sales — different or excluded regimes on ACCC pages; this guide focuses on physical goods sold online after ACL commenced (ACCC: Consumer rights and guarantees (business)).
- Skip the helpdesk CTA if counsel-approved major/minor macros already run in your inbox with correct AU policy links.
Verdict
If you sell directly to Australian consumers from overseas, plan for ACL consumer guarantees: major failure → buyer chooses refund or replacement (full refund, no use deduction); minor failure → free repair first, with refund/replacement if you cannot fix in a reasonable time; change of mind → only if your policy says so. Do not claim "ACL doesn't apply offshore," invent a universal day-count refund clock, or punt buyers to the manufacturer. Not legal advice.
See Gorgias for Shopify support macros
Facts from ACCC (consumer rights and guarantees; repair, replace, refund, cancel; selling online; buying online; contacting a business) and business.gov.au (Australian Consumer Law and your business), opened 6 Nov 2026. Gorgias is third-party (affiliate link). Not legal advice. Physical goods focus.