Scope: This quotes 16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR), opened 10 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT). The eCFR is a continuously updated version of the Code of Federal Regulations; it is authoritative but unofficial. The official legal print edition is the CFR. This is not legal advice and not an FTC ruling. Checklists are our ops recommendations. The rule is about shipment, not carrier delivery.
The pain: a Christmas promise and a dock that cannot keep it
A November banner that says “order by 8 December and it ships the next day” is a shipping time in the solicitation. When Black Friday volume, a supplier delay or a missed cutoff blows that time, the rule does not let you stay silent until the “where is my order” ticket arrives.
16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) makes it an unfair or deceptive act for a seller “to solicit any order for the sale of merchandise to be ordered by the buyer through the mail, via the Internet, or by telephone unless, at the time of the solicitation, the seller has a reasonable basis to expect that it will be able to ship any ordered merchandise to the buyer: (i) Within that time clearly and conspicuously stated in any such solicitation; or (ii) If no time is clearly and conspicuously stated, within thirty (30) days after receipt of a properly completed order from the buyer.” If, at the time of the order, “the buyer applies to the seller for credit to pay for the merchandise in whole or in part, the seller shall have fifty (50) days, rather than thirty (30) days.”
“Arrives by Christmas” is a delivery claim. The Mail Order Rule’s clock is the ship time you stated, or the 30- or 50-day default if you stated none. Do not treat a delivery slogan as a substitute for a ship-by date you can support. If you will miss the ship time that actually applies, send the option the rule requires.
What the delay notice has to do
If you cannot ship within the applicable time, it is a violation “to fail to offer to the buyer, clearly and conspicuously and without prior demand, an option either to consent to a delay in shipping or to cancel the buyer’s order and receive a prompt refund.” The offer must be made “within a reasonable time after the seller first becomes aware of its inability to ship,” and “in no event later than said applicable time.” (16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) (b)(1))
The same paragraph requires the offer to “fully inform the buyer regarding the buyer’s right to cancel the order and to obtain a prompt refund.” If you have a reasonable basis for a definite revised shipping date, state it. If you do not, “the notice shall inform the buyer that the seller is unable to make any representation regarding the length of the delay,” and you need a reasonable basis for saying that. You also may not give a revised date unless you have a reasonable basis for it. (16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) (a)(2), (a)(3), (b)(1)(i))
The consent default changes with the length of the delay:
- If the revised date is 30 days or less later than the applicable time, the buyer is deemed to have consented unless they reject the delay and cancel before shipment and before that revised date. (16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) (b)(1)(ii))
- If the revised date is more than 30 days later, or you cannot give a definite date, the order is automatically deemed cancelled unless you ship within 30 days of the applicable time and receive no cancellation first, or the buyer expressly consents within those 30 days. An indefinite delay also leaves the buyer a continuing right to cancel before actual shipment. (16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) (b)(1)(iii))
If a later revised date also slips, a renewed option is required, with a different default: the buyer is deemed to have rejected a further delay unless they specifically consent. (16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) (b)(2)) You must also “furnish the buyer with adequate means, at the seller’s expense, to exercise such option or to notify the seller regarding cancellation.” (16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) (b)(3))
You may instead decide the order is cancelled yourself and send notice plus a prompt refund. (16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) (b)(4)) When a cancellation option is exercised, or when the automatic-cancel conditions in (c) are met, you must “deem an order cancelled and make a prompt refund.” We are not quoting a day-count for “prompt” here; that definition sits in other sections of part 435, which we did not rely on for this guide.
Records are not optional
In an FTC action, “the failure of a respondent-seller to have records or other documentary proof establishing its use of systems and procedures which assure the shipment of merchandise in the ordinary course of business within any applicable time set forth in this part will create a rebuttable presumption that the seller lacked a reasonable basis” for the ship-time expectation. A similar presumption applies if you cannot show systems that assure compliance with the notice and refund duties. (16 CFR 435.2 (eCFR) (a)(4), (d))
Where a helpdesk belongs in this
The rule does not require a particular helpdesk. Email can meet the duty if the notice is clear, timely, and gives the buyer an adequate way, at your expense, to consent or cancel. At peak volume, the failure mode is a delay that is sitting in someone’s head until after the applicable time has passed.
Gorgias is a helpdesk used by ecommerce stores to send saved replies and macros from the same inbox that already holds the order tickets. Use it to send the delay-or-cancel option as soon as you know a ship date will be missed, and to log that you sent it. That is an operations fit, not a legal stamp. You still have to get the wording, the revised date (or the honest “we cannot say”), and the refund path right.
Set delay-notice macros in Gorgias
Peak-season checklist (our ops recommendations)
- List every ship-by or dispatch time you currently publish — banners, checkout, product pages, ads. If you cannot support it, take it down before you take the order.
- Separate ship dates from delivery slogans. The rule’s clock is shipment. “Arrives by Christmas” still needs a basis; it is not the Mail Order Rule clock by itself.
- Trigger the option as soon as you know you will miss the applicable time, and never later than that time.
- State a definite revised ship date only when you have a reasonable basis. Otherwise say you cannot represent the length of the delay, and use the longer-delay consent rules.
- Make cancellation and the refund easy, at your expense, and keep a record of the notice and the outcome.
- If the order will not ship, cancel it yourself and refund promptly rather than leaving it open.
Who should skip the app
- You already send compliant delay-or-cancel notices from Shopify, email or another helpdesk, on time, with a record. Gorgias is optional.
- You only fulfil from a location, and under terms, that do not involve mail, internet or telephone order sales in US commerce — confirm that with counsel before you assume the rule does not apply.
- This page is not a substitute for a lawyer reading 16 CFR part 435 against your checkout copy.
Verdict
Do not wait for the customer to ask why the Christmas order has not shipped. 16 CFR 435.2 requires a reasonable basis for the ship time you state, and a clear delay-or-cancel offer, without prior demand, no later than that time. Write the notice now, before peak, and use a helpdesk only if it helps you send and record it at volume.
Open Gorgias for holiday delay notices
App facts and prices are from its Shopify App Store listing, checked 10 Nov 2026.