1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. Restocking fees after holiday returns

The January return is approved. The restocking fee is still sitting on the return, not on the refund. Official Shopify Help already says you have to deduct it yourself — if you are allowed to charge it at all.

A restocking fee that looks tidy in the return rules can fail in two different ways in January. Shopify Help, opened 11 Nov 2026 (MYT), says return fees are not automatically deducted from refunds: when you create a refund, you have to deduct them manually. And a UK cooling-off cancellation is not that fee in the first place. Regulation 34 of the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, opened the same date, says the trader must not impose any fee on the reimbursement, and allows a deduction only where the value of the goods is diminished by handling beyond what is needed to establish their nature, characteristics and functioning. This guide keeps the product setting and the legal deduction apart. It is not legal advice.

By Maya from StoreVetted, an AI persona; a human owner reviews what goes live. Updated 11 Nov 2026. Sources linked inline.

Some links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Drafted with AI, checked by a human. How we earn.

Keep restocking decisions on one claims board

Scope: Shopify restocking-fee and return-fee behaviour is quoted from Shopify Help: Setting up return and cancellation rules and Shopify Help: Refunding orders, opened 11 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT). UK cooling-off reimbursement, the no-fee rule, and the diminished-value deduction are quoted from Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 34. The legislation page stated that section 34 was up to date with changes known to be in force on or before 10 November 2026. This is not legal advice and not a ruling on any return. Checklists are our ops recommendations.

The pain: a fee on the return that never hits the refund, or a fee the law does not allow

January staff approve a return, see a restocking percentage on the return, and issue a full refund anyway — because Shopify does not take the fee off automatically. Or they deduct a 15% “restocking fee” from a UK cooling-off cancellation that official regulation 34 describes in different words: no fee on the reimbursement, and only a diminished-value deduction in stated cases. Both failures are louder in January, when gift returns and cooling-off clocks overlap.

Is a restocking fee even the right tool?A Shopify setting is not a UK cooling-off deduction.What right applies?cooling-off, fault, or policyWere rules on at purchase?changes apply to future ordersFee on the returnShopify can display a %Deduct it on the refundnot automaticRecord whyaudit the January queue
Our triage order. Shopify and regulation 34 points below are from official pages opened 11 Nov 2026 (MYT).

What Shopify Help says about restocking fees

Shopify Help: Setting up return and cancellation rules: default return rules include a return window, return shipping costs, and a restocking fee. “Choose whether you want to charge a restocking fee that is a percentage of the return. If you activate the restocking fee, then it’s displayed when customers request a return.” “The restocking fee is displayed when you create a return. You can edit the restocking fee for a specific return, including by item.” “Return fees aren’t automatically deducted from refunds. When you create a refund, you need to manually deduct any applicable return fees.”

The same page says: “Changes to your return rules apply only to future orders. Changes don’t apply to previous orders, so that they don’t impact customers who’ve already placed an order. Turning on return rules is also a change, so it doesn’t apply to items that customers purchased when your return rules were turned off.” If you want a restocking fee on Boxing Day and January returns, the rule had to be on when those orders were placed.

“Tax isn’t calculated on restocking fees.” Starting 23 October 2026, tax may be calculated on return shipping fees for certain US-destination orders when you use Shopify Tax or Tax Platform; that is a shipping-fee tax point, not a restocking-fee point. “If you refund an unfulfilled order, then the restocking fee isn’t displayed. The restocking fee is displayed only if it’s set up and you create a return for a fulfilled order.”

You do not need self-serve returns turned on for restocking fees to apply when you process returns manually from the admin. Self-serve is how the customer sees eligible items and fees in their account.

What regulation 34 allows — and what it does not call a restocking fee

Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, regulation 34 paragraph (8): “The trader must not impose any fee on the consumer in respect of the reimbursement.” Paragraph (9): “If (in the case of a sales contract) the value of the goods is diminished by any amount as a result of handling of the goods by the consumer beyond what is necessary to establish the nature, characteristics and functioning of the goods, the trader may recover that amount from the consumer, up to the contract price.” Paragraph (10) allows that amount to be deducted from the reimbursement, or otherwise paid by the consumer. Paragraph (11): paragraph (9) does not apply if the trader failed to provide the required information on the right to cancel. Paragraph (12): handling is beyond what is necessary “if, in particular, it goes beyond the sort of handling that might reasonably be allowed in a shop.”

That official text is a diminished-value rule, with conditions, not a licence to apply a blanket restocking percentage to a cooling-off cancellation. Get counsel before you deduct anything from a UK (or similar) statutory reimbursement. For the “same means of payment” default, see our store-credit versus refund guide.

Keep restocking decisions on one claims board

Claimify is a third-party claims portal some stores use to keep return, refund and fee decisions in one place. Confirm current plans on its listing. It does not decide whether a restocking fee is lawful, and it does not automatically deduct a Shopify return fee unless you still do that work in the refund. StoreVetted does not own it.

01Is this a UK (or similar) distance-salecancellation under the cooling-off rules?YesRegulation 34(8), openedthis date, says the tradermust not impose any fee onthe consumer in respect ofthe reimbursement.Paragraphs (9) to (12)allow a deduction fordiminished value fromhandling beyond what isnecessary to establish thenature, characteristics andfunctioning of the goods —“in particular, if it goesbeyond the sort of handlingthat might reasonably beallowed in a shop.” That isnot a free-standingrestocking percentage. Getcounsel.No02Is it a change-of-mind return under apublished policy that includes arestocking fee, in a market where thatpolicy can apply?YesShopify Help lets you set arestocking fee as apercentage of the return.It is displayed when thecustomer requests a returnand when you create areturn, and you can edit itper return, including byitem. It is notautomatically taken off therefund — you deduct it whenyou refund. Tax is notcalculated on restockingfees, on the page weopened.No03Were your return rules off when theDecember order was placed?YesShopify Help: changes toreturn rules apply only tofuture orders. Turningrules on is also a change,so it does not apply toitems purchased while ruleswere off. You cannot reachback and add a restockingfee to a Christmas orderthat did not have thatrule.NoEU right-of-withdrawal setup is described onthe same Shopify return-rules page,including a 14-day window from delivery ofthe last item. That is a configuration note,not a finding that your store is compliant.This is not legal advice.01Is this a UK (or similar) distance-salecancellation under the cooling-off rules?YesRegulation 34(8), opened this date, saysthe trader must not impose any fee on theconsumer in respect of the reimbursement.Paragraphs (9) to (12) allow a deductionfor diminished value from handling beyondwhat is necessary to establish thenature, characteristics and functioningof the goods — “in particular, if it goesbeyond the sort of handling that mightreasonably be allowed in a shop.” That isnot a free-standing restockingpercentage. Get counsel.No02Is it a change-of-mind return under apublished policy that includes arestocking fee, in a market where thatpolicy can apply?YesShopify Help lets you set a restockingfee as a percentage of the return. It isdisplayed when the customer requests areturn and when you create a return, andyou can edit it per return, including byitem. It is not automatically taken offthe refund — you deduct it when yourefund. Tax is not calculated onrestocking fees, on the page we opened.No03Were your return rules off when theDecember order was placed?YesShopify Help: changes to return rulesapply only to future orders. Turningrules on is also a change, so it does notapply to items purchased while rules wereoff. You cannot reach back and add arestocking fee to a Christmas order thatdid not have that rule.NoEU right-of-withdrawal setup is described onthe same Shopify return-rules page,including a 14-day window from delivery ofthe last item. That is a configuration note,not a finding that your store is compliant.This is not legal advice.
Restocking fee or a legal deduction? Official pages opened 11 Nov 2026 (MYT).

A configuration note for EU withdrawals, not a compliance stamp

The same Shopify return-rules page, opened this date, says that if you sell to consumers in the European Union, EU Directive 2023/2673 “requires you to give customers an electronic way to exercise their 14-day right of withdrawal. The directive took effect on June 19, 2026. The withdrawal period is measured from the date that the last item in the order is delivered.” It tells you to turn on self-serve returns and cancellations, set the cancellation window to “Until item is fulfilled,” set a return window of at least 14 days starting from delivery of the last item, and “issue refunds within 14 days of the cancellation request under the directive.” It also says: “Using these tools doesn’t automatically make your store compliant.” We are not adding a restocking-fee rule to that directive from this page. Review the setup with counsel.

January checklist (our ops recommendations)

  1. Split statutory cancellations from policy returns before anyone types a restocking percentage.
  2. If you charge a restocking fee where the policy and the law allow it, deduct it on the refund. Shopify Help says it is not automatic.
  3. Do not apply a new restocking rule to orders placed before the rule was on.
  4. Edit the fee per item when one SKU was tried on as in a shop and another was worn for a week — Shopify allows per-item edits; regulation 34, where it applies, is about diminished value, not a flat SKU rate.
  5. Say in the published policy whether a change-of-mind return has a restocking fee, and in which markets.

Who should skip the app

Verdict

Shopify Help, opened 11 Nov 2026, lets you set a restocking fee as a percentage of the return, shows it on the return, and still requires you to deduct it manually when you refund. Changes to those rules apply only to future orders. For a UK cooling-off cancellation, regulation 34, opened the same date, says there must be no fee on the reimbursement, and allows only a diminished-value deduction in the cases it describes. Do not treat those two official texts as the same rule. This is not legal advice.

Open Claimify if you want those deductions in one place

App facts and prices are from its Shopify App Store listing, checked 11 Nov 2026.

FAQ

Does Shopify automatically take a restocking fee off the refund?

No. Shopify Help, opened 11 Nov 2026, says return fees are not automatically deducted from refunds. You deduct them when you create the refund. The fee can be edited per return, including by item.

Can I charge a restocking fee on a UK 14-day cooling-off return?

Regulation 34(8), opened this date, says the trader must not impose any fee on the reimbursement. Paragraphs (9) to (12) allow a deduction for diminished value from handling beyond what is necessary to establish the nature, characteristics and functioning of the goods, with conditions. That is not the same as a blanket restocking percentage. Get counsel. This is not legal advice.

If I turn on a restocking fee now, does it apply to Christmas orders?

Shopify Help: changes to return rules apply only to future orders. Turning rules on is also a change, so it does not apply to items purchased while the rules were off.

Are Claimify links affiliate links?

Yes. Claimify links are sponsored/affiliate links. StoreVetted may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Claimify is a third-party app, not a StoreVetted product. This is not legal advice.

Keep reading

Free tool: Restocking-fee impact calculator · Hub: Holiday returns and ops hub