1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. Split-shipment Christmas orders going missing

One gift arrived. The other fulfilment may still be unfulfilled, untracked, or sitting at a different location.

A Christmas order is not always one box. Shopify Help on fulfilling orders, opened 12 Nov 2026 (MYT), says if items cannot be fulfilled together, the order is split into multiple Unfulfilled sections, and you need to fulfil each one separately. You can add a separate tracking number and send a separate notification for each fulfilment that you ship. The split-shipping page, opened the same date, says a cart splits when it includes pre-orders, subscriptions, products shipping from different locations, products from different shipping profiles, or Buy with Prime products — and the customer cannot choose how the products are split. A “where is my order?” ticket in the week after Christmas often means one fulfilment was delivered and another was not. This guide stays with those official controls.

By Maya from StoreVetted, an AI persona; a human owner reviews what goes live. Updated 12 Nov 2026. Sources linked inline.

Some links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Drafted with AI, checked by a human. How we earn.

Track every fulfilment in one view

Scope: Fulfilment and tracking behaviour is quoted from Shopify Help: Fulfilling your own orders individually and Shopify Help: Split shipping in Shopify Checkout, opened 12 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT). The return-window start options are quoted from Shopify Help: Setting up return and cancellation rules. Checklists are our ops recommendations. This is not a ruling on any order.

The pain: “It was delivered” — but only half the order was

A customer emails on 27 December. Tracking says delivered. The sweater is on the doorstep. The second item, shipped from another location or held as a pre-order, is not. If your macro answers “your order was delivered,” you have answered the wrong fulfilment. Shopify treats those as separate jobs.

Treat each fulfilment as its own shipmentOne delivered scan is not the whole order.Why did it split?location, preorder, profileFulfil each sectionnot optional if checkout split itAdd tracking per fulfilmentseparate email each timeAnswer the missing boxnot the delivered one
Official Shopify Help opened 12 Nov 2026 (MYT).

Why Shopify splits the order

Shopify Help: Fulfilling your own orders individually, opened this date: “If all of the items in an order can be fulfilled together, then they’re grouped in a single Unfulfilled section. If they can’t be fulfilled together, then the order is split into multiple Unfulfilled sections, also known as fulfillments, and you need to fulfill each fulfillment separately.” An order is split when it contains items that no single location has enough inventory to fulfil on its own; items that cannot ship together, “which checkout splits into separate shipments automatically, such as pre-order items, subscription items, or items in different shipping profiles”; or a mix of shipped items and in-store pickup items.

Shopify Help: Split shipping in Shopify Checkout, opened this date, lists the same idea at checkout: an order is split into multiple shipments when it includes pre-orders, subscriptions, separate products shipping from different locations, products from different shipping profiles, or Buy with Prime products. “A customer can’t choose how the products in their cart are split.” By default, checkout “selects the lowest total shipping cost for all shipments in the order.” If you did not want two boxes, check shipping profiles and location fulfilment settings before peak, not after the ticket arrives.

If checkout already split the order, “fulfilling part of the order isn’t optional. You need to fulfill each fulfillment separately, although you might be able to merge some of them first.” You can also split a fulfilment yourself if an item is out of stock or is a pre-order, so the in-stock items can ship first.

Tracking is per fulfilment, not per order

Shopify Help: Fulfilling your own orders individually: “Each fulfillment in an order is fulfilled separately, so a customer can receive more than one shipping confirmation email for an order that has multiple fulfillments.” You can add a tracking number during fulfilment or after. “You can add a separate tracking number and send a separate notification for each fulfillment that you ship.” If you add more than one tracking number in the same Fulfilled section, “All tracking numbers must be from the same carrier.”

If the carrier is not fully supported, you can enter a tracking URL manually. “The URL is used on the order status page to link to the carrier’s tracking page.” Delivery photos, where the carrier provides them, “remain visible on the order for up to 90 days.” “If you use Shopify Payments, then delivery photos from some carriers are added to your chargeback response automatically.” That evidence is still about the fulfilment that was photographed, not about a second box that never left the other warehouse.

Put every fulfilment’s tracking in one place

Track123 is a third-party order-tracking app some stores use so customers can see more than one shipment on a tracking page. Confirm current plans on its listing. It does not fulfil the second package for you, and it does not change how Shopify splits an order. StoreVetted does not own it.

01Does the order have more than oneUnfulfilled or Fulfilled section inShopify?YesShopify Help, opened thisdate, says each fulfilmentis fulfilled separately,and a customer can receivemore than one shippingconfirmation email. Addtracking in the Fulfilledsection for thatfulfilment, not as if theorder were a singlepackage.No02Is only one tracking number on the order?YesThe same Help page says youcan add a tracking numberduring fulfilment orafterwards, and you can addmultiple tracking numbers.If you add more than one inthe same Fulfilled section,all of those numbers mustbe from the same carrier. Asecond fulfilment can haveits own carrier.No03Does the customer say it was delivered,but part of the order is missing?YesSome carriers, such asFedEx, may provide adelivery photo. ShopifyHelp, opened this date,says a delivery photo canremain visible on the orderfor up to 90 days, and ifyou use Shopify Payments,delivery photos from somecarriers are added to yourchargeback responseautomatically. A photo ofone box does not prove thesecond fulfilment arrived.NoIf your return window starts from eachitem’s delivery date, the first gift’swindow may already be running while thesecond fulfilment is still in transit.Shopify Help on return rules, opened thisdate, also lets you start the window fromdelivery of the last item in the order.01Does the order have more than oneUnfulfilled or Fulfilled section inShopify?YesShopify Help, opened this date, says eachfulfilment is fulfilled separately, and acustomer can receive more than oneshipping confirmation email. Add trackingin the Fulfilled section for thatfulfilment, not as if the order were asingle package.No02Is only one tracking number on the order?YesThe same Help page says you can add atracking number during fulfilment orafterwards, and you can add multipletracking numbers. If you add more thanone in the same Fulfilled section, all ofthose numbers must be from the samecarrier. A second fulfilment can have itsown carrier.No03Does the customer say it was delivered,but part of the order is missing?YesSome carriers, such as FedEx, may providea delivery photo. Shopify Help, openedthis date, says a delivery photo canremain visible on the order for up to 90days, and if you use Shopify Payments,delivery photos from some carriers areadded to your chargeback responseautomatically. A photo of one box doesnot prove the second fulfilment arrived.NoIf your return window starts from eachitem’s delivery date, the first gift’swindow may already be running while thesecond fulfilment is still in transit.Shopify Help on return rules, opened thisdate, also lets you start the window fromdelivery of the last item in the order.
Is the missing Christmas gift a second fulfilment? Official pages opened 12 Nov 2026 (MYT).

Return windows can start from the last item

Shopify Help: Setting up return and cancellation rules, opened this date, lets you start the return window from “Item’s delivery” or from “Delivery of last item in order,” so “the whole order shares one return window.” If you start from each item’s delivery date, the first gift’s clock can be running while the second fulfilment is still in transit. For customers in the European Union, the same page says to set a return window of at least 14 days and start it from delivery of the last item in the order. Changes to return rules apply only to future orders.

Peak-season checklist (our ops recommendations)

  1. Open the order and count the Unfulfilled and Fulfilled sections before you answer a “delivered but missing” ticket.
  2. Add tracking on each fulfilment and leave the customer notification on unless you have a reason to silence it. Shopify says the customer can get more than one shipping email.
  3. Do not merge facts across boxes. A delivery photo or delivered scan applies to the fulfilment it belongs to.
  4. Check why the order split — location stock, pre-order, shipping profile, or ship-and-pickup — so the next cart does not surprise you.
  5. Decide how your return window starts for split holiday orders: each item’s delivery, or the last item in the order.

Who should skip the app

Verdict

Shopify Help, opened 12 Nov 2026, says an order can split into multiple fulfillments, and each one is fulfilled, tracked and emailed separately. One delivered box is not a delivered order. Answer the missing fulfilment, and decide whether your return window starts from each item or from the last item in the order.

Open Track123 if you want a shared tracking page

App facts and prices are from its Shopify App Store listing, checked 12 Nov 2026.

FAQ

Why did a Christmas order ship in two boxes?

Shopify Help, opened 12 Nov 2026, says an order splits when no single location can fulfil it, when checkout splits items that cannot ship together (including pre-orders, subscriptions and different shipping profiles), or when some items are picked up in store and others are shipped. The customer cannot choose how products are split.

Can I put both tracking numbers on one fulfilment?

You can add more than one tracking number in a Fulfilled section, but Shopify Help says all of those numbers must be from the same carrier. A second fulfilment can have its own tracking and its own carrier.

How long do delivery photos stay on the order?

Shopify Help, opened this date, says delivery photos remain visible on the order for up to 90 days, and only for fulfillments that have a delivered status from the carrier. Carriers do not take a photo for every delivery.

Are Track123 links affiliate links?

Yes. Track123 links are sponsored/affiliate links. StoreVetted may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Track123 is a third-party app, not a StoreVetted product.

Keep reading

Free tool: WISMO ticket cost estimator · Hub: Holiday returns and ops hub