Scope: SHIPAID platform fees, volume tiers, the $0 monthly fee, the keep-the-item $0.75 charge, and the exchanges FAQ are quoted from SHIPAID official pricing, opened 10 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT). The Shopify listing comparison, including the 4.8 rating from 25 reviews, is quoted from Shopify App Store: SHIPAID listing, opened the same date. Route’s $0/month Standard plan and Custom options are quoted from Route official pricing; the Route listing’s “visit route.com/pricing” line and the 4.0 rating from 375 reviews are quoted from Shopify App Store: Route listing, both opened this date. Route’s protection take-rate is not published on the pricing page we opened, so it is not quoted. StoreVetted has an affiliate link for SHIPAID and does not have one for Route. StoreVetted does not own either product. No claim-payout outcome is promised.
SHIPAID, as the official pricing page publishes it
SHIPAID official pricing, opened 10 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT), describes “No monthly fees, setup costs, minimums, or commitments.” Delivery Guarantee is billed as a platform fee on guarantee revenue only:
- Fewer than 200 monthly orders: 15% platform fee, merchant keeps 85%.
- 200–500 monthly orders: 12%, merchant keeps 88%.
- More than 500 monthly orders: 9%, merchant keeps 91%.
“The platform fee applies only to Delivery Guarantee revenue, never the order total.” “A fee applies only when a customer buys Delivery Guarantee.” The FAQ repeats that both Delivery Guarantee and Returns have a $0 monthly software fee, and that revenue-share and usage charges still apply.
Returns on the same page are usage-based at $0/month. A keep-the-item resolution is listed at $0.75, “Charged only after the resolution is completed.” “Rejected, abandoned, canceled, duplicate, test, and incomplete requests are not charged.” The FAQ states: “Are exchanges supported? No. Exchanges are not currently available.”
Shopify App Store: SHIPAID listing, opened the same date, says the app is free to install, that additional charges may apply, and that “External charges may be billed by ShipAid separately from your Shopify invoice.” The only plan text on the listing is: “9% of Shipping Guarantee Revenue earned using the app (based on monthly order volume).” That is narrower than the official 15% / 12% / 9% table. The listing also describes “Free returns and automated exchanges.” That exchanges line does not match the official FAQ on this date. Confirm with SHIPAID. The listing rating is 4.8 from 25 reviews (24 five-star, 1 one-star).
Route, as official pages publish it — no invented take-rate
Route official pricing, opened the same date, is titled around zero monthly cost. Standard is listed at $0/month, with “consumer funded pricing, customized for the problems you want to solve. No monthly or hidden fees.” It describes shopper opt-in to package protection, free returns, unified platform access, and eligibility for a Merchant Incentive Program. Custom is “Custom pricing,” with “Flat fee, volume based, and consumer funded pricing options,” monthly billing, and API / custom integrations. The page did not print a percentage of protection revenue in the version we opened, so we are not quoting one.
Shopify App Store: Route listing, opened the same date, says the app is free to install, that additional charges may apply, and “Please visit route.com/pricing to learn more.” External charges may be billed by RouteApp LLC separately from the Shopify invoice. The listing rating is 4.0 from 375 reviews (264 five-star; 72 one-star). We are not treating that rating as a quality score you can spend; it is the number on the listing this date. There is no Route affiliate CTA on this page.
Who should skip each option
- Skip SHIPAID if you need exchanges today — the official FAQ says they are not currently available, even though the Shopify listing still mentions automated exchanges. Skip it too if you already run Route and are happy, or if you only wanted carrier declared-value coverage.
- Skip Route, for now, as a like-for-like budget comparison if you need a published take-rate before you can model the bill. Confirm current fees with Route. This page will not invent them.
- Skip both checkout guarantees if you only needed a claims portal for your own warranty process, or a tracking page with no protection add-on.
Verdict
SHIPAID’s official pricing page, opened 10 Nov 2026, charges $0 a month and 15%, 12% or 9% of Delivery Guarantee revenue at the listed volume tiers. Its FAQ says exchanges are not currently available, which disagrees with the Shopify listing’s “automated exchanges” line. Route’s official page lists Standard at $0/month with consumer-funded pricing, without a published take-rate on the version we opened. Confirm live fees. There is no Route affiliate link here.
See SHIPAID’s Delivery Guarantee pricing
App facts and prices are from its Shopify App Store listing, checked 10 Nov 2026.