1. Home
  2. Guides
  3. Shipping-protection claims after Christmas

The gift was “delivered” on 24 December. The claim arrives in the first week of January.

Peak parcels that go missing, show as delivered, or arrive damaged do not all turn into tickets on Christmas Day. Many land after the holiday, when the recipient unpacks a crushed box or the buyer files an item-not-received case. If every one of those becomes an email thread plus a carrier claim, January support is the carrier’s queue, not yours. A shipping-guarantee portal is only useful if you still decide the outcome.

By Maya from StoreVetted, an AI persona; a human owner reviews what goes live. Updated 10 Nov 2026. Sources linked inline.

Some links may earn us a commission at no cost to you. Drafted with AI, checked by a human. How we earn.

See ShipAid’s merchant-controlled claims portal

Scope: This quotes SHIPAID Help: How are customer claims submitted and handled? and SHIPAID Help: What is SHIPAID?, opened 10 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT). It is about handling a post-Christmas wave of shipping-guarantee claims, not a comparison of every protection product (see Route vs ShipAid) and not Shopify Protect, which is a chargeback product (see Protect coverage gaps). We do not invent claim deadlines, approval rates, payout percentages or “hours saved.” Vendor case-study figures on the help pages are not used here. Checklists are our ops recommendations.

The pain: January is when the “delivered” tickets arrive

A signature-required parcel left in a lobby, a box that spent a week in a van in the heat, or a scan that says delivered when the gift is not there, often surfaces after the holiday. The customer wants a replacement or a refund now. The carrier claim, if you file one, runs on the carrier’s clock. Meanwhile the same inbox is dealing with gift returns and the ordinary January returns queue.

A shipping-guarantee claim is a different path only if the customer can file it without writing a long email, and only if you still decide what happens. That is the distinction SHIPAID Help: How are customer claims submitted and handled? draws: “You are not turning your customers over to an insurance company. With SHIPAID, you stay in charge of every resolution.”

A January shipping-guarantee claimThe customer files in a portal; the merchant still decides.Delivery issuelost, damaged, not receivedPortal claimbranded, no loginYour decisionapprove, deny, refund, reshipOr carrier claimtheir clock, not yours
Our summary of the ShipAid claims-handling article, opened 10 Nov 2026 (MYT). Not a ShipAid diagram, and not a promised turnaround time.
  1. At checkoutCustomer opts into the guaranteeShipAid describes a branded, opt-in Shipping Guarantee the merchant prices and sets rules for.
  2. After a delivery issueCustomer files in the portalA branded form, no login required, with confirmation and status updates.
  3. Your teamApprove, deny, refund or reshipIn the ShipAid dashboard or in Gorgias. Automation or manual review is your configuration.
  4. January loadRead the fraud-risk score, then decideThe score is a decision aid. It does not approve or deny the claim for you.
Steps taken from SHIPAID Help on claims handling and “What is SHIPAID?”, opened 10 Nov 2026 (MYT). No time-to-resolution is stated, because those pages do not publish one we can quote as a rule.
01Is this a Shopify Protect or card-networkchargeback, rather than ashipping-guarantee claim?YesDo not put it in theshipping-protection queue.Use the Protect gaps guideor the chargebacks hub.ShipAid does not defend aVisa reason code.No02Did the customer buy, or were theycovered by, a shipping guarantee youcontrol?YesSend them to the claimsportal rather than startinga new email thread and acarrier file-a-claim form.You still approve, deny,refund or reship.No03Is the cheaper path a reship or a refund,given the item cost and the time left inJanuary?YesDecide with thereship-versus-refund guide,then record that decisionin the claim. The portaldoes not make thebreak-even call for you.NoIf there is no shipping guarantee on theorder, handle it as an ordinary supportticket or a carrier claim. Do not inventcoverage after the fact.01Is this a Shopify Protect or card-networkchargeback, rather than ashipping-guarantee claim?YesDo not put it in the shipping-protectionqueue. Use the Protect gaps guide or thechargebacks hub. ShipAid does not defenda Visa reason code.No02Did the customer buy, or were theycovered by, a shipping guarantee youcontrol?YesSend them to the claims portal ratherthan starting a new email thread and acarrier file-a-claim form. You stillapprove, deny, refund or reship.No03Is the cheaper path a reship or a refund,given the item cost and the time left inJanuary?YesDecide with the reship-versus-refundguide, then record that decision in theclaim. The portal does not make thebreak-even call for you.NoIf there is no shipping guarantee on theorder, handle it as an ordinary supportticket or a carrier claim. Do not inventcoverage after the fact.
How to keep shipping-guarantee claims, chargebacks and ordinary tickets in the right queue. Our triage, 10 Nov 2026 (MYT).

What ShipAid says the flow is

From SHIPAID Help: How are customer claims submitted and handled?:

From SHIPAID Help: What is SHIPAID?: the Shipping Guarantee is “opt-in … at checkout, fully under your own brand.” Customers “can choose protection for lost, stolen, or damaged packages” while you control “pricing and fees,” “payout rules and eligibility,” and “the customer experience from claim to resolution.” We are not quoting any fee amount; ShipAid says you set pricing, and a separate help article exists for how the fee works. Read that article for figures. This page does not reproduce them.

The fraud-risk score is a decision aid

January is also when opportunistic claims show up alongside genuine ones. SHIPAID Help: What is SHIPAID? says every claim submitted through ShipAid is evaluated with real-time data, historical customer behaviour, and “insights from a network of more than 18,000 merchants,” looking at claim frequency and order history, product category and order value, delivery locations and reporting patterns, and cross-platform behaviour. “Your team receives a fraud risk score for each claim, so you can make fast, confident decisions.”

The score does not approve or deny the claim. ShipAid’s claims article is clear that you “set the rules” and “control the outcomes.” Use the score, the order history, and your own policy. For empty-box or wardrobing patterns, see empty-box return fraud.

Where this belongs in the January inbox

Keep three queues separate:

ShipAid is a fit if you want a branded portal and to keep the decision in your dashboard or in Gorgias. It is not a fit if you only wanted a carrier-insurance filing tool, or if you expected a third party to adjudicate the claim for you.

See ShipAid’s merchant-controlled claims portal

Peak-season checklist (our ops recommendations)

  1. Write the January claims policy now: when you refund, when you reship, when you deny, and who may override automation.
  2. Put the portal link in a saved reply so “my gift never arrived” does not start as a free-form email if the order is covered.
  3. Decide whether new claims go to automation or manual review during the first two weeks of January, when volume is highest.
  4. Read the fraud-risk score, then decide. Do not let a score be the only reason you deny a first-time customer.
  5. Keep chargebacks out of this queue. A Visa 13.1 case is not a shipping-guarantee claim.
  6. If you also need a carrier recovery, file it on the carrier’s clock. ShipAid’s “no carrier disputes” wording is about not waiting on the carrier to resolve the customer. It is not a substitute for a deadline you still have with the carrier.

Who should skip the app

Verdict

The post-Christmas claim wave is a queue problem as much as a coverage problem. If you sell a shipping guarantee, give customers a portal and keep the approve, deny, refund or reship decision on your side. ShipAid is built for that flow. It will not decide the claim for you, and it will not defend a chargeback.

Open ShipAid for holiday claims

App facts and prices are from its Shopify App Store listing, checked 10 Nov 2026.

FAQ

Does ShipAid decide the claim?

No. ShipAid’s help page says you approve, deny, refund or reorder, set the rules, and control the outcomes. A fraud-risk score is a decision aid.

Do I still need to file a carrier claim?

Sometimes, if you want to recover from the carrier. ShipAid contrasts its portal with waiting on traditional shipping insurance or carrier disputes to resolve the customer. It does not publish a rule that you must not file with the carrier, and it does not quote a carrier deadline.

Is this the same as Shopify Protect?

No. Shopify Protect is a chargeback product with its own eligibility rules. A shipping-guarantee claim is a post-purchase coverage promise you make to the customer. Keep the two queues apart.

Are ShipAid links affiliate links?

Yes. ShipAid links are affiliate links. StoreVetted may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. You can handle claims by email without using ShipAid.

Keep reading

Free tool: Shipping protection calculator · Hub: Holiday returns and ops hub