Scope: Subflow prices, caps, the 14-day paid trial, the free-plan rule, dunning, import sources and prepaid limits are quoted from Subflow Shopify App Store listing, Subflow official FAQ and Subflow official site, all opened 11 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT). Recharge figures are from Recharge Shopify App Store listing. Skio figures are from Skio Shopify App Store listing and Skio official pricing. Appstle figures are from Appstle Subscriptions Shopify App Store listing. Bold figures are from Bold Subscriptions Shopify App Store listing. Stay AI figures are from Stay AI Shopify App Store listing. Shopify’s first-party app is quoted from Shopify Help: Subscriptions. All charges on those App Store listings are billed in USD. StoreVetted has an affiliate link for Subflow only. There is no /go/ CTA for Recharge, Skio, Appstle, Bold, Stay AI or Shopify Subscriptions. Subflow is a third-party app, not a StoreVetted product. Review counts are the numbers on the listings this date, not a quality score you can spend.
The pain: the renewal fee is not the same kind of bill as the monthly plan
A subscriptions product has to charge on a schedule, let the customer skip, pause or update a card, and recover a declined payment. A fourth job, if you are leaving another app, is an import that does not double-charge. The bill for that work is either a flat monthly price, a percentage of subscription revenue or transactions, or both. Official pages opened this date show both models. Compare them on the same unit — what you pay each month, and whether the app also takes a cut of each charge — rather than on review count alone.
Subflow, as official pages publish it
Subflow official FAQ, opened 11 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT), answers “What do the plans cost?” as: “Free is $0 for up to 50 active subscriptions. Starter is $19 a month for up to 500. Growth is $49 a month for up to 2,000. Pro is $149 a month with no subscriber cap. Paid plans carry a 14-day free trial and the charge appears on your Shopify bill.” “Do you take a cut of my subscription revenue? No. You pay a flat monthly price and nothing else — 0% transaction fee on every plan, including Free.” The Free plan “has no end date” and “is not a trial.”
The same FAQ says that when you reach a cap, Subflow detaches products from the selling plan so no new subscribers are taken; existing subscribers keep billing. A downgrade that leaves you over the cap starts a 30-day window; after that, subscriptions the plan does not cover are paused, newest first, not cancelled. “Prepaid plans — pay for three months up front, receive three — are deliberately not supported.” Discounts are “a percentage off”; “Percentage is the only discount type.” Failed charges are retried three times: 2 days after the failure, then 4 days later, then 7 days later, “three attempts spread over about two weeks,” with a customer email each time.
Subflow Shopify App Store listing, opened the same date, matches those four plans and 0% transaction fees, lists a 14-day free trial on the paid tiers, and says you can “Upload your export from Recharge, Appstle, Seal, Bold or Shopify Subscriptions” and “preview every row first.” The listing rating is 0.0 from 0 reviews. It gives a launch date of 18 August 2026. Payment-provider fees still apply — Subflow official site says so.
Official prices, opened 11 Nov 2026 (MYT)
| App | Published monthly price | Published app transaction fee | Listing rating, this date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Subflow | Free $0 (up to 50); Starter $19 (500); Growth $49 (2,000); Pro $149 (unlimited) | 0% on every plan | 0.0 from 0 reviews |
| Shopify Subscriptions | Shopify Help calls it “the free first-party Shopify Subscriptions app.” No separate app price was listed on that page. | Not stated on the Help page we opened | Not a third-party listing |
| Appstle Subscriptions | Free up to $500/month subscription revenue; Starter $10/month or $96/year (up to $5,000); Business $30 or $288/year (up to $15,000); Business Premium $100 or $960/year (up to $100,000) | “0% Transaction Fee & No Hidden Charges” on the paid plans we opened | 5.0 from 9,245 reviews |
| Bold Subscriptions | Launch $24.99; Grow $49.99; Scale $74.99. Launch lists unlimited subscribers and a 30-day free trial. | Launch +2%; Grow +1%; Scale +0.9% | 4.0 from 379 reviews |
| Recharge | Starter $149/month (60-day free trial); Scale $499/month. The listing also says “See all pricing options.” | Starter 1.50% + 20¢; Scale 1.25% + 20¢, “with scalable transaction rates” | 4.8 from 3,155 reviews |
| Stay AI | Monthly Plan $299/month. The listing said a free trial is available, and showed a 30-day free trial on the plan card. | 1% + 19¢ per transaction | 4.9 from 148 reviews |
| Skio | Scale $599/month, or $5,988/year. Skio’s own pricing page lists the annual option as $499/month billed annually. Enterprise is “Custom.” | 1.25% + 20¢, “orders involving a subscription” on skio.com/pricing | 5.0 from 247 reviews |
Sources for the table are the official pages named in the scope note, opened 11 Nov 2026 (Asia/Kuala_Lumpur / MYT). The Shopify App Store pages also said “All charges are billed in USD.”
The other apps, as their official pages publish them — no invented plans
Shopify Help: Subscriptions says you can add a subscription as a purchase option “if you're using the free first-party Shopify Subscriptions app or a third-party subscription app from the Shopify App Store.” If you uninstall a third-party app, “any subscription data, excluding subscription contracts and customer payment information, that you've created in the app is deleted after 48 hours.”
Recharge Shopify App Store listing: Starter is $149 / month with 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction and a 60-day free trial. Scale is $499 / month with 1.25% + 20¢ per transaction with scalable transaction rates to support your growth. “External charges may be billed by Recharge separately from your Shopify invoice.” The listing is rated 4.8 from 3,155 reviews and gives a launch date of 14 October 2014. It also says “See all pricing options.” We did not open a separate options page, so we are not quoting a cheaper Recharge plan.
Skio Shopify App Store listing: the Scale plan is $599 / month “or $5,988/year and save 17%,” with a 1.25% + 20¢ transaction fee. The listing is titled “Skio, a Recharge Company,” rated 5.0 from 247 reviews, launched 27 April 2021. Skio official pricing lists the same Scale plan as $499/month (Annually) or $599/month (Monthly) and says the 1.25% + 20¢ fee applies to “orders involving a subscription.” Enterprise is “Custom.” The same page notes “there is an additional charge for Skio loyalty.”
Appstle Subscriptions Shopify App Store listing: Free, “Upto $500 in subscriptions per month.” Starter $10 / month or $96/year, “Sell up to $5,000/month in subscription revenue,” “0% Transaction Fee.” Business (Biz) $30 / month or $288/year, up to $15,000. Business Premium $100 / month or $960/year, up to $100,000. The listing is rated 5.0 from 9,245 reviews, launched 8 April 2021. Paid plans showed a 14-day free trial.
Bold Subscriptions Shopify App Store listing: Launch $24.99 / month +2% transaction fee, with unlimited subscribers, dunning, prepaid subscriptions and a 30-day free trial. Grow $49.99 / month +1%. Scale $74.99 / month +0.9%. The listing is rated 4.0 from 379 reviews, launched 15 October 2020.
Stay AI Shopify App Store listing: “Monthly Plan” $299 / month with 1% + 19¢ per transaction. The listing header said a free trial is available, and the plan card showed a 30-day free trial. Rated 4.9 from 148 reviews, launched 11 January 2022.
Who should skip each option
- Skip a third-party app if Shopify’s free first-party Subscriptions app already covers checkout disclosure, reminders, and skip, pause or cancel in the customer account, and you are happy with that.
- Skip Subflow if you need prepaid “pay for three, receive three” plans — the official FAQ says they are not supported — or a fixed-amount discount rather than a percentage. Skip it too if you will not accept a listing with 0 reviews and an 18 August 2026 launch date without a test order first. January is a bad moment to migrate a live cohort.
- Skip Recharge, on the figures we opened, if a $149 Starter month plus 1.50% + 20¢ is more than you want to spend at small volume. We are not inventing a cheaper plan from “See all pricing options.”
- Skip Skio if $599 a month, or $5,988 a year, plus 1.25% + 20¢ is past your budget, or you wanted a published free plan. It is listed as a Recharge Company.
- Skip Appstle if a revenue cap is the wrong meter for your catalogue, or a feature you need sits on a higher listed tier (Build-a-Box is described on the Business plan, not on Free or Starter, on the listing we opened).
- Skip Bold if you do not want a percentage transaction fee on top of the monthly price. Launch lists 2%, Grow 1%, Scale 0.9%.
- Skip Stay AI if $299 a month plus 1% + 19¢ is more than the programme is worth, or you wanted a published free tier.
Verdict
Subflow’s official FAQ and Shopify listing, opened 11 Nov 2026, still publish $0, $19, $49 or $149 a month and 0% transaction fees, with a free plan that is not a trial. That is a different bill from Recharge ($149 + 1.50% + 20¢ at Starter, on the listing we opened), Skio ($599 a month or $5,988 a year plus 1.25% + 20¢), Stay AI ($299 + 1% + 19¢), or Bold ($24.99–$74.99 plus 2%, 1% or 0.9%). Appstle lists revenue-capped plans with 0% transaction fees on the paid tiers we opened. Shopify’s own Subscriptions app is described as free and first-party. Subflow had 0 App Store reviews on this date. Confirm live prices. There is no affiliate link here for the other apps.
Open Subflow — free plan up to 50 subscribers
App facts and prices are from its Shopify App Store listing, checked 11 Nov 2026.